Newburgh Four: Judge orders release of three men jailed in synagogue bomb plot sting

In scathing opinion, judge says FBI agents invented conspiracy in sting operation against 'Newburgh Four'

David Williams was one of three members of the Newburgh Four who were freed by a US judge. AP

Three men convicted more than a decade ago of plotting to blow up New York City synagogues, a Jewish community centre and shoot down military planes, were ordered to be released from prison by a judge who said they had been manipulated by the FBI.

In a scathing opinion against the FBI, the presiding judge called the men “hapless” petty criminals who were “easily manipulated” by the government in a sting operation.

The men to be released are: Onta Williams, David Williams and Laguerra Payen, who were three of what became known as the “Newburgh Four”.

A fourth man, James Cromitie, did not seek compassionate release and is expected to serve until 2030.

Lawyers for the men could not immediately be identified by Reuters to seek comment.

US District Judge Colleen McMahon wrote in her 28-page order filed on Thursday that all four men were caught up in a scheme in 2009 to attack the synagogues, community centre and launch stinger missiles at military aircraft, driven by overzealous FBI agents and an “unsavoury” confidential informant.

A representative for the FBI was not immediately available to comment.

The judge granted compassionate release to three men and reduced their sentence to time served plus 90 days, citing concerns for the men's health and her own qualms about the original 25-year-sentence she imposed on the men in 2011.

Cromitie was described as the ringleader by prosecutors during the trial.

But Ms McMahon wrote that he was a small-time “grifter” who was penniless and unemployed when he was enlisted in the FBI-driven plot, who provided fake bombs to plant in exchange for $250,000.

Cromitie enlisted the other three men to serve as lookouts, the judge wrote.

“Nothing about the crimes was the defendants' own doing. The FBI invented the conspiracy,” Ms McMahon wrote.

Officials portrayed Cromitie as the ringleader of a “chilling plot” among “extremely violent men” loyal to a Pakistani terrorist group – though the government later decided not to present any evidence about foreign terrorist organisations at trial.

A court complaint described him as a man seething with anti-American and anti-Semitic sentiment and eager to translate those feelings into bloody action.

Agencies contributed to this report.