Partisan politics and poor planning add to Pakistan drought woes

Observers say relief work is only a temporary fix and Islamabad needs to address the root causes of such disasters and warn they are likely to be repeated.

A woman displaced from a drought-stricken area in Tharkarpar with her children at a hospital in Sindh province. Akhtar Soomro / Reuters / March 11, 2014

MITHI, PAKISTAN // As the death toll from the latest outbreak of poverty-driven diseases in Pakistan’s Thar desert nears 100 children, experts warn that poor planning and a dysfunctional political system make a repeat of the disaster almost inevitable.

The desert region in Tharparkar, one of Pakistan’s poorest districts, spreads over nearly 20,000 square kilometres in the south-east and is home to some 1.3 million people, including a large population of minority Hindus.

Between March 2013 and February this year, rainfall was 30 per cent below usual, according to government data, with the worst-hit towns of Diplo, Chacro and Islamkot barely touched by a drop of water for months.

Asif Ikram, a top administration official in the district, said on Thursday that the death toll from diseases such as pneumonia and meningitis since December 1 had risen to 161 people, including 97 children.

Last week, the UAE sent 1,500 tonnes of aid, including infant formula, flour, rice, sugar, salt, lentils, cooking oil and tea to Tharparkar in response to the crisis.

Life in the desert is closely tied to rain-dependent crops and animals, with farmers relying on beans, wheat, and sesame seeds for survival, bartering surplus in exchange for livestock.

The drought is not the only reason for the recent deaths, observers say they have come about as a result of endemic poverty, exacerbated by the drought and an outbreak of disease killing livestock.

Authorities have been busy dispensing food aid and sending medics to attend to the sick following visits by the prime minister, Nawaz Sharif, and Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, who leads the Pakistan People’s Party which rules the province.

But observers say the relief work fails to address the root causes of such disasters and warn they are likely to be repeated.

A drought in the desert in 2000 killed 90 per cent of the livestock.

Politics at play

Zafar Junejo, chief executive of Thardeep Rural Development Programme (TRDP), says the region has long been ignored by Karachi, the provincial capital, because it is not considered an important constituency politically.

According to the last census, Hindus make up 40 per cent of the district’s population, unlike most of Pakistan which is overwhelmingly Muslim, and Mr Junejo said the authorities have little concern for the suffering of minority communities.

“We are fortunately or unfortunately a mixed Hindu and Muslim population,” he said.

“Fortunate because we are living in peace and harmony unlike the rest of the country where radicalisation is in vogue. But also unfortunate because being Hindu and being secular we do not fit in the official ideological definition of the country.”

Javed Jabbar, founder of Banh Beli non-government organisation which works in the area, said: “When you have Karachi with 18 million people, Tharparkar is relatively less important from a political radar point of view.”

Mr Jabbar, a former federal information minister, said the district has fallen victim to “a failure to enforce accountability due to considerations of partisanship” that has afflicted the province for years.

He cited the case of five doctors in the province who were able to keep their jobs despite being absent from their posts for years, because of connections to political patrons.

Lessons to learn

Residents and activists say the effects of drought can be mitigated by global lessons in dry regions, such as the conservation of rainwater.

“Rainwater harvesting should be made mandatory all over the country and especially in this part,” said Abid Channa, a social activist, complaining of the district’s lack of reservoirs despite decades of disasters.

Jairam Das, 49, a farmer who lost 10 sheep and two goats to the recent outbreak of animal disease, said he and other villagers were envious of Indian villages just a few kilometres away.

“In the bordering town of India there is greenery all around as their government has spread a network of irrigation and piped drinking water,” Mr Das said.

“We have a similar climate but the lack of water is a major hurdle.”

In India, the 400-kilometre Indira Gandhi canal through the Thar desert in Rajasthan state is a lifeline for isolated communities and farmers who use the water for irrigation for crops and drinking water when needed.

Mr Jabbar, the former minister, said more planning was needed ahead of droughts.

“When you see signs in a particular year, you move supplies of fodder and nutritional supplements in advance of the drought not after it.”

* Agence France-Presse