Survivors will face New Zealand mosque gunman at sentencing

A total of 51 people were killed when a gunman opened fire at two Christchurch mosques in March last year

Aya Al Umari holds a photo of herself and her brother Hussein, who was killed in the Christchurch mosque attacks in March 2019. AP

When Aya Al Umari faces her brother’s killer in the dock, she intends to tell him that his hatred stole away her best friend, her guardian, her hero. That she still wants to pick up the phone and tell her brother all about her day, because he is the only one who would understand.

Ms Al Umari is one of more than 60 survivors and family members who this week in court will confront the white supremacist who committed the worst atrocity in New Zealand’s modern history, when he slaughtered 51 worshippers at two Christchurch mosques in March 2019. The gunman pleaded guilty in March to 51 counts of murder, 40 counts of attempted murder and one count of terrorism – the first terrorism conviction in the nation’s history.

The murderer has dismissed his lawyers and intends to represent himself during the four-day sentencing starting on Monday, raising fears he could try to use the occasion as a platform to promote his racist views. He can choose to speak once the victims have spoken, although the judge will probably shut down any attempts he makes to grandstand.

He could become the first person in New Zealand to be sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. New Zealand abolished the death penalty for murder in 1961, and the longest sentence imposed since then has been life imprisonment with a minimum 30-year non-parole period.

The attacks targeting people praying at Al Noor and Linwood mosques shocked the nation and prompted new laws banning the deadliest types of semi-automatic weapons. They also prompted global changes to social media protocols after the gunman live-streamed his attack on Facebook, where it was viewed by hundreds of thousands of people.

Some survivors have travelled from abroad to attend the court hearing and have completed a mandatory 14-day quarantine imposed because of coronavirus.

Social-distancing requirements mean the number of survivors in the main courtroom will be limited to 35 at any one time. But the hearing will also be streamed to seven adjacent courtrooms, which can hold about another 200 people.

Judge Cameron Mander said he realised the court process had been “exhausting and frustrating” for many of the victims. “Finality and closure is considered by some as the best means of bringing relief to the Muslim community,” he wrote in a court memo.

Mr Mander is not allowing live reporting from the sentencing and has reserved the right to ban some things that are said in court from being broadcast or published. Survivors and relatives of victims also can choose to remain anonymous.

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern, who was praised around the world for her empathy and leadership after the attacks, said she would be monitoring the hearing closely. She said the sentencing would be hard for the victims.

“I don’t think there is much that I can say that is going to ease just how traumatic that period’s going to be,” she said.

Andrew Geddis, a law professor at the University of Otago, said the case was unprecedented in New Zealand, in the magnitude of the crime and the number of victims involved in the sentencing.

He said it was possible the judge would impose the first all-of-life sentence, with two possible mitigating factors being the accused’s guilty plea and his young age.

Mr Geddis said if he showed any remorse during the hearing, it may factor in his favour, while any attempt he makes to promote his racist agenda will likely count against him.

The gunman moved to New Zealand in 2017 and kept a low profile in the university city of Dunedin. He frequented a gym, practised shooting at a rifle club range and built an arsenal of weapons. He did not appear to be employed, and said in some online posts that he had inherited a significant sum of money when his father died.

He appeared to have a fascination with religious conflicts in Europe and the Balkans, and visited sites in Eastern Europe in the years before he committed the massacre. After his attack at the second mosque, he was driving, possibly to carry out a shooting at a third mosque, when two police officers rammed his car off the road, dragged him out and arrested him.

Ms Al Umari’s 35-year-old brother Hussein was among those killed at Al Noor mosque. In her victim impact statement, she says that she mourns not only the loss of her brother, but also the loss of his hopes and goals, and that she will never have any nieces or nephews.

“There are no words that do justice to explain what it is like to go from having lunch with your brother on one day to burying him on another,” she writes.