Coronavirus: defectors question North Korea's zero-virus claims

Outsiders suspect the virus has already spread to North Korea, which has quarantined tens of thousands and delayed the school year as a precaution

In this March 17 photo provided by the North Korean government, leader Kim Jong Un, left, delivers a speech during the ceremony of a general hospital in Pyongyang, North Korea. North Korea says it hasShow more

As a doctor in North Korea during the Sars outbreak and flu pandemic, Choi Jung Hun had little more than a thermometer to help him decide who should be quarantined.

Barely paid, with no test kits and working with antiquated equipment, if anything, he and his fellow doctors in the northeastern city of Chongjin were often unable to determine who had the disease, even after patients died, said Choi, who fled to South Korea in 2012.

Health officials were not asked to confirm cases or submit them to the central government in Pyongyang, Choi said in an interview with The Associated Press.

Experts said North Korea’s reluctance to admit major outbreaks of disease, its wrecked medical infrastructure and its extreme sensitivity to any potential threat to leader Kim Jong-un’s authoritarian rule meant that Pyongyang was likely to be handling the current coronavirus pandemic in the same manner.

This has led to widespread scepticism about the nation’s claim to have zero infections.

“It’s a lie,” Choi, 45, said. “Year after year, and in every season, diverse infectious diseases repeatedly occur but North Korea says there isn’t any outbreak.”

Outsiders suspect that coronavirus, which has infected more than 2.4 million people, has already spread to North Korea because it shares a long, porous border with China, its most important trading partner and biggest aid benefactor. China is where the first known coronavirus cases were reported in December.

North Korea, which has quarantined tens of thousands and delayed the school year as precautionary steps, officially sealed its border with China in January, but smuggling across the frontier still likely happens. Activist groups in Seoul said they have been told by contacts in North Korea that people had died of the virus. Those claims cannot be independently verified.

While there have been no reliable outside reports of mass infections in North Korea yet, the country’s tight control on information allowed few foreign experts to assert with an authority that the North’s quarantine regime has been successful.

As seen in Singapore, the coronavirus can surge again, and North Korea’s powerful Politburo said last week it would further bolster anti-epidemic steps.

“I think a considerable number of people could die. But that won’t be disclosed to the outside world because the North is not even able to diagnose patients with (the coronavirus),” said Kim Sin-gon, a professor at Korea University College of Medicine in Seoul.

He said North Korea was struggling to treat seriously ill patients, and said that UN reports found that about 40 per cent of its 24 million people were undernourished.

Russia’s foreign ministry said in February it donated 1,500 coronavirus test kits to North Korea, and observers said similar kits have also been shipped there from China. Some relief agencies, including Unicef and Doctors Without Borders, said they sent gloves, masks, goggles and hand hygiene products.

North Korea’s main newspaper recently called its public health system “the most superior in the world” and said that Mr Kim’s devotion to improving it was the reason there were no infections.

North Korea’s socialist free medical service collapsed in the mid-1990s amid economic chaos and a famine that killed an estimated hundreds of thousands. In recent years, Mr Kim has built new hospitals and modernised some medical facilities as the economy improved, but most of the medical benefits still largely go to his ruling elite, analysts said.

Dozens of refugees interviewed in a recent study said they felt the North’s health care system has become poorer under Mr Kim, according to Min Ha-ju, a North Korean refugee-turned-researcher. She said the gulf between the haves and the have nots in terms of medical service was deepening because a crumbled state rationing system has led to a burgeoning private economy.

Mr Choi said his monthly salary was the equivalent of about 2 kilograms (4.4 pounds) of rice and that he received cigarettes from patients in return for telling them what medicine they should buy at markets.

Cho Chung-hui, a former local North Korean official who is now with the Seoul-based NGO Good Farmers, said he gave cash to doctors to cure gastritis and enteritis.

Mr Choi and Mr Cho said measles, chickenpox, cholera, typhoid, paratyphoid, hepatitis and tuberculosis repeatedly swept through North Korea when they were there. Mr Choi said he wore no masks, gloves or protective gear during outbreaks and used equipment manufactured in the 1960-70s.

During the 2002-2003 Sars outbreak, Mr Choi said, hundreds of people in Chongjin died after suffering flu-like symptoms during eight months of intense quarantine.

“But no (doctors) can dare to diagnose the dead with Sars. There wasn’t an order to confirm the cause of their deaths, and we didn’t have diagnostic kits,” said Mr Choi, now a researcher at a Korea University-affiliated institute.

During a 2009 flu pandemic, he said he did not have diagnostic kits and asked patients with fevers what antibiotics they had used before placing some under quarantine. After many patients died, he speculated their deaths were likely to have been linked to the flu.

In a highly unusual admission of a disease outbreak apparently aimed at winning outside aid, North Korea’s state media said in December 2009 that nine people in Pyongyang and the northwestern border town of Sinuiju had contracted the flu.

Some said North Korea may not have big clusters of infections because it does not have densely populated cities and strictly restricts freedom of movement and association. But many others disagreed, saying all North Koreans were required to attend diverse state-organised group activities and a lack of adequate sanitation could worsen outbreaks. There are also questions about the workings of North Korea’s quarantine campaign.

The North’s medical system is like a “a broken rusty pistol which doesn’t even have a bullet because it hasn’t been maintained for a long time,” Mr Choi said.