Coronavirus: study of Singapore and Tianjin outbreak says some Covid-19 infections linked to asymptomatic carriers

The early-stage Belgian-Dutch research suggests that almost half of those who caught the coronavirus in Singapore did so from someone not showing symptoms

Patients lie in bed at a temporary emergency structure set up outside the accident and emergency department, where any new arrivals presenting suspect new coronavirus symptoms will be tested, at the Brescia hospital, Lombardy, on March 13, 2020. / AFP / Miguel MEDINA

Syrian boys pose for a picture during an awareness workshop on Coronavirus held by Doctor Ali Ghazal at a camp for displaced people in Atme town in Syria's northwestern Idlib province, near the border with Turkey. AFP

Australia's Prime Minister Scott Morrison speaks during a press conference in Sydney, Australia, 15 March 2020. EPA

US President Donald Trump looks at US President Mike Pence while answering a question during a news conference in the briefing room of the White House. Bloomberg

Tourists taking photos in front of a cruise liner docked at Station Pier as Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison on March 15 announces all cruise ships will be banned entirely from docking in Australia. AFP

US Vice President Mike Pence takes a question during a news conference in the briefing room of the White House. Bloomberg

A man wearing a protective mask with a LinkNYC box displaying Coronavirus Prevention Tips in New York City. AFP

A LinkNYC box displays Coronavirus Prevention Tips in New York City. AFP

People visit an almost empty Times Square in New York City, New York, U.S. Reuters

A sign indicates that the National Gallery of Art has been closed to the public due to the coronavirus threat in Washington, US. Reuters

Expatriates wait for mandatory coronavirus testing in a makeshift testing centre in Mishref, Kuwait. Reuters

People applaud Spanish health workers in Madrid, Spain. Getty Images

A worker in a protective suit disinfects the Fatih Mosque in Istanbul, Turkey. Reuters

Members of the Hellenic Red Cross check the temperature of Greek soldiers who wait to enter the Kastanies border crossing area with Turkey's Pazarkule, Greece. Reuters

A Chinese woman wears a protective mask as she has her temperature checked by a security guard before entering a shopping area in Beijing, China. Getty Images

Health personnel take the temperature to people who enter the National Palace in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic. EPA

People wearing face masks walk along a rapeseed farm where canola oil is taken in Jiujiang, China’s central Jiangxi province. AFP

Staff members accompanying South African citizens who have been repatriated from Wuhan, China, where they were working when the COVID-19 novel coronavirus erupted, wave to bystanders as they drive in a police escorted convoy on a bus en route to The Protea Hotel Ranch Resort in Polokwane, where they will be quarantined. AFP

Indian doctors screen patients as a precautionary measure for Coronavirus in Nehru Homoeopathic Medical College and Hospital in New Delhi, India. EPA

A man wears a mask while cycling around Mexico City. EPA

Players of Tigres warm up in an empty stadium prior to the 10th round match between Tigres UANL and FC Juarez as part of the Torneo Clausura 2020 Liga MX at Universitario Stadium in Monterrey, Mexico. Getty Images

A face mask used to protect from the coronavirus disease is seen on the ground near Trump Tower in New York City, New York, U.S. Reuters

A new study suggests about half of people who have caught Covid-19 in Singapore appeared to do so from others who were yet to show any symptoms.

The pre-print study, which has not been peer reviewed, analysed data from clusters in Singapore and Tianjin in China to work how the virus is transmitted and how long it takes people to develop signs of it.

In Singapore, 48 per cent of people on average, caught the virus from someone who had not started showing symptoms. In Tianjin, it was even more, at 62 per cent of people, according to the researchers in Belgium and the Netherlands.

On average, it took sufferers in Singapore five days to develop signs of the disease, compared to almost four days in Tianjin.

The study was posted on MedRxiv, a server for papers that have not yet been published.

The World Health Organisation’s emerging diseases and zoonoses unit recently said preliminary data showed patients shed more virus in the early stages of the illness, including before they start to show symptoms.

"That is something which is in observational data, and fairly well documented in multiple communities, not just in China," said Dr Ravi Arora, a specialist in internal medicine at NMC Speciality Hospital in Abu Dhabi.

"Asymptomatic transmission is something we were not expecting, not prepared for, but it seems to be happening. And it increases the spectre of the disease much more because practically anyone, even before they start coughing, is potentially a spreader of the bug. That again makes it a lot less containable and the spread highly imminent."

The US Centres for Disease Control and Prevention has said that "we are still learning how" Covid-19 spreads because it is a new disease.

"Some spread might be possible before people show symptoms; there have been reports of this occurring with this new coronavirus, but this is not thought to be the main way the virus spreads," according tot the CDC website.

Other preliminary research has also shown that the pathogen can survive in the air for up to three hours.

However, researchers said that even if aerosol transmission is possible, it is unlikely to be the main source driving the pandemic.

"The current scientific consensus is that most transmission via respiratory secretions happens in the form of large respiratory droplets ... rather than small aerosols," co-author Dylan Morris, a graduate student in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at Princeton University, was quoted as saying by Live Science, a website which focuses on science news.