MANCHESTER UNITED RATINGS: David de Gea 7 - Another game where United failed to keep a clean sheet – the 12th and the worst record since 1963-64. Fine double save after 71 minutes in his 50th Champions League game – which kept his side in the game. Deserved to be on the winning side. AP

Manchester United ratings v Atalanta: Ronaldo 7, Rashford 6, United fans 9