Preaching hatred of Islam does not help Christians

A US conference supposed to protect persecuted religious minorities in the Middle East was anything but, writes James Zogby.

Frank Gaffney, founder and president of the Center for Security Policy, was a speaker at a contentious conference about persecuted religions. Win McNamee / Getty Images / AFP

Last week, a coalition of mostly far-right Christian organisations hosted a conference in Washington that claimed to be defending persecuted minorities in the Middle East. Given the very real threat facing vulnerable ancient religious communities at the hands of barbarous groups such as ISIL, one might be inclined to commend the organisers. However, an examination of the groups involved and the list of invited speakers shows that the conference’s purposes appear to be dangerously provocative.

Among the featured speakers are a handful of notorious Islamophobes and a strange collection of individuals who claim to have been “radical Muslims” of one stripe or another, all of whom say they have now converted to Christianity and have come forward to tell their conversion stories.

One of the listed headliners was Frank Gaffney who heads an organisation that the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) identifies as an “anti-Muslim hate group”. Mr Gaffney is one of the main propagators of the notion that president Barack Obama “may be a Muslim” and that a Hillary Clinton aide, Huma Abedin, is a secret operative of the Muslim Brotherhood.

Another speaker representing an SPLC-listed hate group is retired general William Boykin, a Bush-era Pentagon official who gained notoriety when it was revealed that he had repeatedly compared the Iraq war to the Crusades, boasting that the US/Christian side was bound to win because “our God is bigger than theirs”. Gen Boykin has also said that “Islam is evil” and should not be protected by the First Amendment.

Among the others scheduled to address the event were a number of evangelical preachers, Donald Trump supporters, and Christian missionaries devoted to converting Muslims.

The organisers invited some converts to share their stories. One of them, Tass Saada, claims to have been a PLO sniper until he saw the light and converted to Christianity. He founded the Hope for Ishmael group to encourage other Muslims to convert. Another speaker, Daniel Shayesteh, is an Iranian American who claims to have been an Islamic extremist at the age of 9. He became a Christian and founded the group Exodus from Darkness.

It was especially troubling that a number of conservative Republican Members of Congress and State Department officials were scheduled to speak at the conference. Their presence was intended to give it legitimacy.

On being made aware of the conference, my organisation, the Arab American Institute, wrote to the Congress members urging them to withdraw their support, detailing the dangers this gathering posed for the very people it claimed to be supporting. Endorsed by the Holy Land Christian Ecumenical Foundation, the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, the Muslim Public Affairs Council and the Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good, our letter, in part, read: “We write to you to convey our deep concern with an upcoming conference, The Bridge: The Annual Conference on the Persecuted Church ... The conference’s programme gives a platform to well-known anti- Arab and anti-Muslim activists whose work advances a dangerous agenda of fear and misunderstanding.

“We share with you the belief that it is of utmost importance to defend the rights of persecuted Christians and other vulnerable faith communities across the Middle East. Moreover, we believe that it is critical that we work to ensure that these faith communities not merely be protected as minorities but guaranteed full and equal citizenship rights in every country in the region. While some in Washington, DC believe that the interests of persecuted Christians can be advanced through bashing Islam and its adherents, the truth is that these tactics do nothing to advance or defend the rights of persecuted Christians.

“At a time when the public discourse in the United States has looked at Arabs and Muslims across the world with acute suspicion, it is critically important that our public officials help combat hateful rhetoric and elevate leaders who speak to our highest ideals of mutual respect and understanding ... We are concerned that this conference may have the unfortunate consequence of legitimising the anti-Arab and anti-Muslim messages and policies that are associated with its speakers, and will in the end do more harm than good to the persecuted communities the conference organisers claim to be defending.

“We believe that your participation and/or endorsement of this event would empower these voices of bigotry, not defend the rights of religiously persecuted Christians, as the conference claims to do. With these considerations in mind, we respectfully request that you withdraw from participating in this event.”

The members of Congress did not withdraw, but on the day before the conference was to begin Mr Gaffney’s name was removed from the list of speakers.

Dr James Zogby is the president of the Arab American Institute

On Twitter: @aaiusa