President Isaac Herzog of Israel. AP
President Isaac Herzog of Israel. AP
President Isaac Herzog of Israel. AP
President Isaac Herzog of Israel. AP

Israeli president hopes judicial overhaul becomes 'constitutional moment'


Thomas Helm
  • English
  • Arabic

Negotiations between Israel's government and the opposition over plans to implement controversial judicial reforms could move Israel towards a "stronger and more resilient [democratic] structure", President Isaac Herzog said.

The two sides are in compromise talks mediated by the president after Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu delayed the plans in late March after criticism from his own defence minister and mass protests and a general strike against the overhaul.

In an interview with The New York Times released on Wednesday, Mr Herzog said the negotiations represented "potential for a constitutional moment".

Israel does not have a constitution. Its democracy is instead built on four branches: the presidency, parliament, the ministerial cabinet and the judiciary.

  • Israeli police disperse demonstrators blocking a road in Tel Aviv during a protest against plans by the government to overhaul the judicial system. AP
    Israeli police disperse demonstrators blocking a road in Tel Aviv during a protest against plans by the government to overhaul the judicial system. AP
  • Police arrest a protester in Tel Aviv. EPA
    Police arrest a protester in Tel Aviv. EPA
  • Demonstrators set up a bonfire on a road. AP
    Demonstrators set up a bonfire on a road. AP
  • Israeli security forces use a water cannon to disperse protesters. AFP
    Israeli security forces use a water cannon to disperse protesters. AFP
  • Thousands of protesters block the Ayalon main road. EPA
    Thousands of protesters block the Ayalon main road. EPA
  • The Tel Aviv protest swelled on Saturday to about 200,000 demonstrators, according to Israeli media estimates. AFP
    The Tel Aviv protest swelled on Saturday to about 200,000 demonstrators, according to Israeli media estimates. AFP
  • A roadblock placed by protesters on the Ayalon main road. EPA
    A roadblock placed by protesters on the Ayalon main road. EPA
  • Demonstrations erupted in January after the coalition government announced its package of changes. AFP
    Demonstrations erupted in January after the coalition government announced its package of changes. AFP
  • Israeli protesters dislodge a fence. AFP
    Israeli protesters dislodge a fence. AFP
  • Police use a water cannon to disperse protesters. AP
    Police use a water cannon to disperse protesters. AP
  • An aerial view of the protest. Reuters
    An aerial view of the protest. Reuters
  • Plans to hand more control to politicians and diminish the role of the court have been questioned by Israel’s allies including the US. AFP
    Plans to hand more control to politicians and diminish the role of the court have been questioned by Israel’s allies including the US. AFP
  • Protesters with placards of Prime Minister Netanyahu saying 'We will not forget, we will not forgive'. EPA
    Protesters with placards of Prime Minister Netanyahu saying 'We will not forget, we will not forgive'. EPA

"I’m carrying a certain historic burden on my shoulders ... I’m perhaps the only element in Israeli public life that all parties can feel free to come and speak to and confide with," he said.

The government's judicial reforms include plans to limit the power of the courts – including the Supreme Court – and give the government more control over the selection of judges and legal experts.

Protests against the overhaul have divided the country since the new Israeli government came into power last December.

Every Saturday for three months, hundreds of thousands of Israelis have taken to the streets, with other days of mass action interspersed with the regular protests.

The situation reached breaking point towards the end of March when a general strike and warnings from the country's security cabinet about the overhaul's effects on Israel's safety forced Mr Netanyahu to delay the process until parliament begins its summer session at the end of April.

Defence Minister Yoav Gallant said that Israel's enemies were emboldened by the country's social divisions and mounting threats from Israeli military reservists that they would not turn up to training in protest against the overhaul.

Benjamin Netanyahu agreed to delay the judicial reforms last month. Bloomberg
Benjamin Netanyahu agreed to delay the judicial reforms last month. Bloomberg

He was later sacked by Mr Netanyahu, although he was never removed from his position. Mr Netanyahu later re-instated him as defence minister after an exchange of rockets fired between Israel and terrorists in Gaza, Lebanon and Syria and a spate of terrorist attacks in Israel and the Palestinian territories last week.

In his interview this week, Mr Herzog reiterated fears that enemies regard the country's internal divisions as a sign of weakness.

The president, whose position is normally largely ceremonial, has been issuing notably intense pleas for dialogue and calm.

In March he released a compromise plan on the reforms. The opposition welcomed the framework, but it was rejected by the government.

Updated: April 13, 2023, 8:17 AM