Sanctions by US and its allies miss richest Russian oligarchs

The financial sanctions may do little to dim the jet-setting lifestyles of Russia’s ultra-rich

A Russian soldier attends a military exercise at the Golovenki training ground in the Moscow region, Russia. AP Photo

A member of the 14th Separate Mechanised Brigade of the Ukrainian Armed Forces takes part in anti-aircraft military drills in the Volyn region, Ukraine. Reuters

People walk past a sign reading 'I Love Ukraine' in the central square in Kiev. EPA

Russian naval frigate 'Admiral Essen' sails during an exercise in the Black Sea. AP

Employees of essential city industries and services attend a military training session outside Lviv, Ukraine. Reuters

Airman 1st Class Olabode Igandan organises ammunition, weapons and other equipment bound for Ukraine during a foreign military sales mission at Dover Air Force Base, Delaware. AP

A member of the public waves a Ukrainian flag at a rally attended by soldiers and police in Odessa, Ukraine. Bloomberg

A Ukrainian serviceman patrols the front line near Avdiivka village, not far from the pro-Russian militant-controlled city of Donetsk, Ukraine. EPA

A Belgian Air Force F-16 fighter jet participates in Nato's Baltic Air Policing Mission in Lithuanian airspace. AP

The term Russian oligarch conjures images of posh London mansions, gold-plated Bentleys and sleek superyachts in the Mediterranean, their decks draped with partiers dripping in jewels.

But the raft of sanctions on oligarchs announced by US President Joe Biden this week in response to the invasion of Ukraine may do little to dim the jet-setting lifestyles of Russia’s ultra-rich and infamous — much less force a withdrawal of tanks and troops.

US sanctions target Russian President Vladmir Putin and a handful of individuals believed to be among his closest security advisers, including Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov.

But the list is just as notable for who isn't on it — most of the top names from Forbes' list of the richest Russians whose multi-billion dollar fortunes are now largely intertwined with the West, from investments in Silicon Valley start-ups to British Premier League football teams.

Citing the concerns of European allies, the US also didn’t impose what was seen as the harshest punishment at its disposal, banning Russia from Swift, the international financial system that banks use to move money around the world.

Mr Biden said on Thursday the new US sanctions would nonetheless cripple Russia’s financial system and stymie its economic growth by targeting Russia’s biggest banks, which the Treasury Department said holds nearly 80 per cent of all the country’s banking assets.

But much of the wealth of Russia’s richest isn’t held in the sanctioned Russian banks. Mr Putin and the oligarchs aligned with him have had decades to stash assets overseas, much of it hidden in ways specifically designed to avoid sanctions.

Although the Kremlin officially reports Putin’s income at $131,900 annually, the Russian president is believed to benefit from many billions in cash and overseas assets held by trusted friends and relatives, many of whom are from his home city of St Petersburg.

A 2017 study of Russian oligarchs published by the US-based National Economic Bureau estimated that as much as $800 billion is held by wealthy Russians in the United Kingdom, Switzerland, Cyprus and similar offshore banking centres.

That vast fortune, held by a few hundred ultra-rich individuals, is roughly equal to the wealth of the entire rest of the Russian population of 144 million people.

Some oligarchs have also obtained dual citizenship in Britain and other western countries, adding legal complications to attempts to unilaterally seize their assets.

An example is Roman Abramovich, a former Russian provincial governor and Mr Putin's ally who became a steel and metals magnate. Now a dual Israeli citizen with a net worth estimated at more than $13bn, Mr Abramovich used his fortune to buy the British football club Chelsea and has homes in London and New York.

He and his now ex-wife frequently socialised with Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner, the daughter and son-in-law of former president Donald Trump.

Mr Abramovich also owns what is purported to be the world’s most expensive superyacht, the 455-foot Solaris, which features a helicopter hangar, tennis court, pool and berths for about 100 guests and crew.

Also not on the sanctions list is Alisher Usmanov, another Russian metals tycoon who was an early investor in Facebook. His fortune is estimated at more than $14bn.

Mr Usmanov recently sold his stake in the British football club Arsenal for a reported $700 million and, according to Forbes, owns two sprawling estates in London worth a combined $300m. Mr Usmanov’s superyacht, Dilbar, measures 512 feet, even longer than Mr Abramovich’s.

Daniel Fried, a former US official under both Democratic and Republican administrations who helped craft US sanctions against Moscow in the wake of Mr Putin’s 2014 invasion of the Crimean Peninsula, said he was surprised Mr Abramovich and Mr Usmanov weren’t on the sanctions list announced on Thursday, given their long ties to Mr Putin and visible assets in the West.

But, Mr Fried said, sanctioning Russian oligarchs would probably have limited impact on persuading Mr Putin to change course in Ukraine.

“He owns them absolutely. He crushed them and they exist only by his sufferance,” said Mr Fried. “He can jail them and the notion that the oligarchs can assert influence over Putin is foolish.”

Still, he said the opinion of wealthy, educated elites carries some intangible weight that Mr Putin defies at his own risk. While sanctions are unlikely to drive the oligarchs away from Mr Putin, they do raise for them the cost of their continued support.

“They can’t stop or vote him out of office. But he’s only in total control until he isn’t,” said Mr Fried.

The family fortunes of many in Russia’s billionaires date back to the 1990s, the turbulent decade after the fall of the Soviet Union. Under the notoriously corrupt presidency of Boris Yeltsin, such key state-controlled assets as oil refineries, steel mills, aluminum smelters and tractor factories were gobbled up by the politically influential, often purchased with the aid of government-backed loans.

Then, in 1999, Mr Yeltsin unexpectedly resigned and the then-relatively unknown Mr Putin was appointed as acting president.

A former KGB agent, Mr Putin had earlier been appointed by Mr Yeltsin as the head of Russia’s FSB, among the country’s most powerful spying and security agencies.

Mr Putin has ruled Russia for the past 22 years, crushing those who have dared challenge him.

Mikhail Khodorkovsky, an oil baron once believed to be the wealthiest man in Russia, ran afoul of Mr Putin when he more fully embraced the free market and began criticising the vestiges of Soviet central planning.

Mr Khodorkovsky was arrested by Russian authorities in 2003 and charged with fraud, money laundering and embezzlement. After spending a decade in jail, he was released in 2013 and fled to London, where he now leads a foundation, the Dossier Centre, dedicated to exposing criminal activity by Kremlin insiders.

Boris Berezovsky, a mathematician turned Mercedes-Benz dealer who amassed a fortune by acquiring the country’s main television channel at the end of the Soviet era, was tried in absentia on charges of fraud and embezzlement after fleeing to London in 2000.

He was found dead on the bathroom floor of his home in southern England in 2013. His daughter said he feared he had been poisoned after losing a major court battle against Mr Abramovich, his former business partner. Originally believed to be a suicide, a coroner recorded the cause of death as inconclusive.

“Every oligarch owes the preservation of their wealth to the Kremlin,” said Max Bergmann, a senior fellow at American Progress, who also served at the State Department during the Obama administration.

“The oligarch class is an important pillar of the Putin regime and is heavily exposed because their assets are held in the West — in villas in the South of France, condos in Trump properties and in sports teams.”

Maria Shagina, a sanctions expert at the Helsinki-based Finnish Institute of International Affairs, said European countries are seeking to insulate their own economic interests from the effects of sanctions, whether that’s natural gas piped to Germany, diamonds imported from Siberian mines or Italian luxury cars and designer handbags sold in Moscow or St Petersburg.

“We see that Europeans don’t want to bear any sanctions cost,” Ms Shagina said. “It is painful for everyone.”

But, the experts said, the sanctions announced this week will cause pain and eventually force the Kremlin to make hard budgetary choices by weakening the Russian economy.

Most Russians are significantly poorer than their Western counterparts. The Russian Federation ranks 83rd in per capita gross domestic product, at a little under $11,000 per person, according to 2020 data compiled by the World Bank. That’s less than a third of the average for the European Union and about one-sixth of per-capita GDP for the United States.

"Putin will have to choose between putting money into his military or paying pensioners,” Mr Bergmann said. “So sanctions serve to degrade Putin’s power and strength over the long term."

In the meantime, wealthy Russians are investing in cryptocurrencies and using other emerging strategies to protect their fortunes.

“Sanctions enforcement is inherently a cat-and-mouse game,” said Marhsall Billingslea, who helped set sanctions policy for the Trump administration, “and they’ve had eight years, ever since Crimea, to set up alternative mechanisms to keep hard currency flowing to the regime.”