Why the wish of emerging economies to end dollar's dominance is easier said than done

At next week's Brics summit, grievances will be aired – but, still, no concrete proposals are expected

Dollar and naira bills at a currency exchange in Lagos, Nigeria. The greenback's strength against the Nigerian currency has pushed the price of garments and other foreign goods beyond the reach of manShow more

Business has vanished at Kingsley Odafe’s clothing shop in Nigeria’s capital, forcing him to lay off three employees.

One culprit for his troubles stands out: the US dollar's strength against the Nigerian currency, the naira, has pushed the price of garments and other foreign goods beyond the reach of local consumers.

A bag of imported clothes costs three times what it did two years ago. The price these days is running around 350,000 naira, or $450.

“There are no sales any more because people have to eat first before thinking of buying clothes,” Mr Odafe said.

Across the developing world, many countries are exasperated by America's dominance of the global financial system, especially the power of the dollar.

They will air their grievances next week as the Brics bloc of Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa meet other emerging market countries in Johannesburg, South Africa.

But griping about King Dollar is easier than deposing the de facto world currency. The dollar is by far the most-used currency in global business and has shrugged off challenges to its pre-eminence many times.

Despite repeated talk of the Brics countries rolling out their own currency, no concrete proposals have emerged in the run-up to the summit starting on Tuesday. Emerging economies have, however, discussed expanding trade in their own currencies to reduce their reliance on the buck.

At a meeting of Brics foreign ministers in June, South Africa's Naledi Pandor said the bloc's New Development Bank will seek alternatives “to the current internationally traded currencies” – a euphemism for the dollar.

Ms Pandor was sitting alongside Russia's Sergey Lavrov and China's Ma Zhaoxu – representatives of two countries that are eager to weaken America's international financial clout.

The Brics grouping dates to 2009. Originally, it was just Bric, a term coined by Goldman Sachs economist Jim O'Neill to refer to the rising economies of Brazil, Russia, India and China.

South Africa joined in 2010, adding the “s”. More than 20 countries – including Saudi Arabia and Venezuela – have expressed interest in joining Brics.

In 2015, the Brics countries launched the New Development Bank, an alternative to the US and European-dominated International Monetary Fund and World Bank.

“Developing nations are itching to loosen the grip of western dominance and open the door to a new world order where the East commands equal, if not greater, influence,” said Martin Ssempa, a Ugandan political campaigner.

Critics in the developing world are especially uneasy about America's willingness to use the dollar's influence to impose financial sanctions against adversaries, as it did to Russia after the invasion of Ukraine last year.

They also complain that fluctuations in the dollar can destabilise their economies. A rising dollar, for instance, can cause chaos abroad by drawing investment out of other countries. It also increases the cost of repaying loans denominated in dollars and buying imported products, which are often priced in dollars.

Kenyan President William Ruto has grumbled this year about Africa's dependence on the dollar and the economic fallout from its ups and downs, while the Kenyan shilling plunges in value.

He has urged African leaders to join a fledgling pan-African payments system that uses local currencies in a push to encourage more trade.

“How is US dollars part of the trade between Djibouti and Kenya? Why?” he asked at a meeting, to applause.

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has supported a common currency for commerce within the South American bloc Mercosur and for trade among Brics nations.

“Why does Brazil need the dollar to trade with China or Argentina? We can trade in our currency,” he told reporters this month.

But if the dollar’s drawbacks are easily apparent, the alternatives to it are not.

“At the end of the day, if you want to keep your reserve safe, you’ve got to put it in the dollar,” said Daniel Bradlow, a senior research fellow at the University of Pretoria and a lawyer specialising in international finance.

“You’re going to need to borrow in dollars. Everybody can see all the problems with doing this, but if there was an alternative, people would use it.”

As it stands, 96 per cent of trade in the Americas from 1999 to 2019 was invoiced in dollars, 74 per cent of trade in Asia and 79 per cent everywhere else, outside of Europe, which has the euro, according to calculations by US Federal Reserve researchers.

Still, the dollar’s hold on global commerce has loosened somewhat in recent years as banks, businesses and investors have turned to the euro and China’s yuan.

But 24 years after the euro was introduced, the world's No 2 currency still does not rival the dollar for international gravitas. The dollar is used in three times as many foreign exchange transactions as the euro, Harvard University economist Jeffrey Frankel said in a study last month.

And the yuan is limited by Beijing's refusal to let the currency trade freely in world markets.

“None of the alternatives to the dollar managed to get to the dominance level,” said Mihaela Papa, senior fellow at Tufts University’s Fletcher School of global affairs. “So the idea that now, overnight, you will have a new Brics currency that would cause a major upheaval – it takes time, it takes trust … I see this path as very long.”

The dollar still has its supporters. In Argentina, Javier Milei, who emerged from primary voting Monday as the front-running presidential candidate in October's general election, is calling for the dollar to replace the country's embattled peso.

In Zimbabwe, Lovemore Mutenha's store collapsed when hyperinflation hit in 2008. He only managed to resuscitate the business when the country abandoned the local currency for a basket of currencies dominated by the dollar.

“The US dollar has given us our life back. We can't do without it,” Mr Mutenha, said in the working-class suburb of Warren Park near the capital, Harare.

“How can one budget with the Zimbabwe dollar that is always changing in value? It is not stable, and we have been burnt before.”

In 2019, the government reintroduced the Zimbabwean currency and banned foreign currencies in local transactions.

But the revamped Zimbabwe dollar foundered. US dollars kept trading in the black market, and the government lifted the ban. Now, 80 per cent of transactions in the country are in US dollars.

Finance Minister Mthuli Ncube often pleads with people to embrace the local currency.

But even government workers clamour to be paid in US dollars, arguing that almost all service providers accept only the greenback.

Prosper Chitambara, an economic analyst in Harare, said the US dollar “has always had a stabilising effect”. But Zimbabwe’s economy, which has little industry, low investment, few exports and high debts, cannot attract enough dollars to meet the needs of everyday commerce.

It has led to a niche business on the streets of the capital: vendors mend worn out or shredded $1 notes for a small fee.